Poor Officiating Or Match Fixing?
5 min readRugby$7.62 pending

Six illegal tackles in the last 3 minutes of the game on 77:12, 77:41, 79:21, 79:30, 80:06, 80:20. This is your profession as a full time rugby referee paid very well and this team is not up to the job.
Last night we had an eye opening press conference with South Africa's rugby coach Rassie Erasmus which was rather revealing. This all kicked off when a reporter asked him how he felt about the citing of one of Irelands rugby players over the weekend? His response was direct stating he thought nothing would happen because he is a Northern Hemisphere player.
Putting This All Into Context
Back on October the 7th World Rugby had a meeting in London between all the coaches and top officials from around the world with regard to knee drop and hip drop tackles. The laws of the game are being addressed to make the sport safer for the players as this is not just about reducing head contact which has been outlawed, but more to do with all types of dangerous tackles.The Irish player Sam Prendergast executed a hip drop tackle over the weekend which resulted in his body or entire weight landing on the opponents legs. The Fijian player was severely injured and had to be stretchered off and the referee never called it as an illegal tackle even though the Fijian players told him to take a look. The television match official (TMO) never took action either even though we all knew this would be a red card. Today that player was cited for the offence and should be banned for 4-6 matches and yet somehow we know he will get away with this. The problem is a player needs to be cited within 12 hours of the match ending and conveniently this is over the 12 hour period so the chances are nothing will happen.
I think legally they had to cite the player in case the injury is career threatening and would leave World rugby exposed on legal grounds. Ignoring any bad call is bad enough, but ignoring it a day or two later leaves them exposed. World Rugby has a class action case against them so ignoring laws put in place that are there to protect the players is not only foolish, but irresponsible.
Rewind to Friday night when South Africa played France in Paris and lost 21-19 with a sub standard refereeing performance by the Italian referee. I called it for what it was at the time and had no idea at the time how bad it was besides the obvious.
The SA team like any other team has analysts and people who are part of the World Rugby officiating conferences. On Friday night I counted maybe 8 or 9 knee drop tackles and since been informed there were a total of 17. Bear in mind these are new laws and have been put in place from November 1st in order to protect the players from serious injury.
When you have 17 illegal tackles in one game it tells you two things and one is the officials both on and off the field are not very good. The other is they purposedly ignored these illegal tackles as we know what the result would be and players would be carded and sent off the field.
One reporter stated maybe the officials missed these tackles but they happened right in front of the referee and there were 17 and not one or two. Players sliding in on their knee as they made contact could not be more clearer and you have to start asking questions why is this being ignored.
Ignoring one or two, but 17 is quite incredible and it is not a shock to think maybe there is some match fixing or agenda going on if it is not down to poor officiating. I mentioned previously this particular referee in my opinion is not very good and the Italian TMO is on the same level.
I know there will be a backlash for what has been said, but the facts are this is the truth and cannot be ignored. For all those who think it is a conspiracy or something that should not be said then sadly the game will never improve with regards to safety which is what should be the most important part. The latest update adding to the post is Rassie Erasmus has received a six match ban which removes him from any match day involvement. SA Rugby has asked for a hearing with World Rugby as what was said was the truth.
an unacceptable attack on the credibility and competence of the match officials.World Rugby.
Yes competence is what is being bought into question here and this needs to be addressed because the proof is right in front of you watching the game.
All the SA rugby can do is send in their video examples and only 5 of them are allowed even though there are so many to choose from. The expected reply will be that mistakes were made and that will be the end of that yet nothing will happen to the officials who screwed up an entire game and are a danger/risk to the players. I would like to see the referee and all officials involved removed from the elite panel for the sake of player safety.
The reason why I took up rugby refereeing in the first place was that there was too many bad calls taking place and officials were so weak game results were being changed by the calls being made. I have always been impartial in my calls and if something is wrong call it for what it is. The players deserve this and the referee is there to blow the game according to the rules whilst looking after player safety. Player safety is what bother me more than anything else and why this ban needs to be fought.